An Exposé: Study 329, Antidepressants, and New Zealand’s Youth Suicide Crisis

Social IssuesTechnology Dec 03, 2024 Tim Baker

The alarming prevalence of antidepressant use among New Zealand’s youth demands urgent scrutiny. According to Ministry of Health data obtained by Kiwis For Good, in 2021, over 10,000 prescriptions for the antidepressant paroxetine were written for individuals under 30, including 1,330 for those under 19. These figures are particularly concerning given the dark history of paroxetine, a drug at the centre of one of the pharmaceutical industry’s most notorious scandals: Study 329.

Study 329: A Stark Warning from History

In the 1990s, GlaxoSmithKline (GSK) conducted Study 329 to evaluate paroxetine’s safety and efficacy in treating adolescent depression. The results were falsified to present the drug as “safe and effective,” masking evidence that it significantly increased suicidal thoughts and behaviours in adolescents. This deliberate deception came to light after independent researchers, led by Dr David Healy, reanalysed the trial and revealed the true extent of the risks. Their findings led to lawsuits, regulatory action, and a “black box warning” for antidepressants in young people.

Despite these warnings, paroxetine continues to be prescribed, raising concerns about whether lessons from Study 329 have been fully absorbed. Its use among New Zealand’s youth has troubling implications in a country already grappling with one of the highest youth suicide rates in the developed world.

New Zealand: A Youth Mental Health Crisis

The prescription of paroxetine to such a significant number of young people raises critical questions. Are healthcare providers fully aware of the risks associated with prescribing this drug to adolescents? Have the potential side effects—such as akathisia, a state of extreme agitation that has been linked to suicidal behaviour—been adequately communicated to patients and their families?

New Zealand’s youth suicide rate remains alarmingly high, highlighting the inadequacy of current mental health interventions. The increasing reliance on pharmaceuticals like paroxetine may be part of the problem, rather than the solution. Study 329 demonstrated that the very medications meant to alleviate depression can, in some cases, exacerbate the risk of self-harm or suicide. This risk is particularly acute among the young and vulnerable.

A Call for Reform and Accountability

The situation demands urgent action to prevent further harm to New Zealand’s youth. Key measures include:

  1. Increased Transparency: Pharmaceutical companies must be required to disclose all trial data to ensure the safety and efficacy of medications prescribed to young people.
  2. Enhanced Oversight: The New Zealand government must reassess its mental health strategies, ensuring antidepressants are only prescribed when absolutely necessary and that robust guidelines are in place to safeguard young patients.
  3. Greater Investment in Alternatives: While innovative programmes like Kiwis For Goods “Heroes Journey” programme are still under development, the focus must shift towards holistic, non-pharmaceutical mental health interventions that build resilience and purpose.
  4. Public Education: Parents, healthcare providers, and young people must be fully informed of the risks associated with antidepressants like paroxetine, empowering them to explore safer and more sustainable treatment options.

The tragic lessons of Study 329 serve as a cautionary tale for New Zealand. The widespread prescription of paroxetine to young people, despite its well-documented risks, suggests that those lessons may have been ignored. New Zealand must act now to prioritise transparency, accountability, and innovative mental health care. By doing so, the nation can move towards a future where young people are supported, not endangered, by the systems meant to protect them.

Boxing & Suicide - An Analogy Social IssuesCulture Boxing & Suicide - An Analogy After many years of indolence, I took up boxing as a way to get fit. I'm in my mid-40s, fat and out of shape so naturally, I decided that I would take up sparring with the fit and really good ones. These are people who for the most part are half my age, they are certainly half my weight, they have twice my speed, twice my stamina and twice my skill... at least. So I get hit... a lot. Read Wayne Hanson: A Journey of Resilience and Hope Social Issues Wayne Hanson: A Journey of Resilience and Hope I was born on 23 October 1971 in Bury St Edmunds, Suffolk, England, to my parents, Eric and Ann Hanson. My childhood was filled with adventure and mischief, and as the eldest of three children, I naturally took on the role of protector and guide to my younger brother and sister. Read How it feels to be a loving but emotionally incompetent man Social IssuesCulture How it feels to be a loving but emotionally incompetent man I’m one of the lucky ones. As a therapist, I see the usual outcome of childhood trauma: broken relationships and lifelong emotional difficulties. The stories shared in a recent documentary about the emotional impact of English boarding schools, ‘Boarding on Insanity’, reminded me of my own experiences and prompted me to share my learning. Read A huge thank you to Kiwis For Good Social Issues A huge thank you to Kiwis For Good Thanks to Kiwis For Good, I not only defended myself against unjust debt collection practices but also regained my sense of dignity. I encourage anyone facing similar challenges to reach out to Kiwis For Good. They are such a great help for those navigating financial crises and unfair debt collection practices. Read The Link Between Antibiotics and Depression: What You Need to Know Social Issues The Link Between Antibiotics and Depression: What You Need to Know Antibiotics are hailed as life-saving drugs, essential in fighting infections. Yet, recent research suggests that these medications may have an unexpected downside—an increased risk of depression. While antibiotics combat harmful bacteria, they also disturb the gut’s delicate balance, which may have a profound impact on mental health. Read Breaking Point: The Mental Health Crisis of Kiwi Firefighters Social Issues Breaking Point: The Mental Health Crisis of Kiwi Firefighters Why are the firefighters striking? In 2013 a memorandum of understanding was signed between FENZ and St John meaning firefighters were ordered to act as co-responders to ambulance call-outs. This has meant that since 2013 our firemen and women now attend all stabbings, shootings, drownings, suicides, cot deaths, choking and more. This has resulted in a 1000% increase in call-outs for firefighters. Read
Help Us Help Others!

Your donations are incredibly important for us, and enable us to use our initiatives to help our fellow Kiwis.

Donate today
Join Our Newsletter

For the latest news and projects, keep up-to-date with our newsletter. We promise not to spam you; we get enough of that ourselves!