Breaking Point: The Mental Health Crisis of Kiwi Firefighters

Social Issues Oct 21, 2022 Tim Baker

Why are the firefighters striking? In 2013 a memorandum of understanding was signed between FENZ and St John meaning firefighters were ordered to act as co-responders to ambulance call-outs. This has meant that since 2013 our firemen and women now attend all stabbings, shootings, drownings, suicides, cot deaths, choking and more. This has resulted in a 1000% increase in call-outs for firefighters.

No mental health resilience training was ever introduced when the extra workload came, however. No firefighter was given training on how to console a grieving mother in the incidence of cot death. The counselling service firefighters currently have available is on a self-referral basis and has what's referred to by unionists as an “invisible cap” meaning only 3 sessions are allowed before firefighters are ushered back to work. Any decent counsellor will tell you this is not nearly enough time to unpack the trauma faced by men and women working in the fire service day to day. The secretary of the Union refers to the counselling service as unfit for purpose.

For Firemen like Brendan Dunn of the Tauranga Fire Brigade, the extra workload and exposure to some of life's most unspeakable tragedies takes a toll. Brendan's candidness and openness about his experiences to us revealed the real pressures of working in a job which led him to depression, anxiety and even suicidal ideation. In a tragic coincidence, Brendan and I share a friend, another fireman, Haydn. Haydn and Brendan completed firefighter training together in 2009. For Haydn, along with two other colleagues of Brendan's the stresses were evidently too great and all three have sadly died by suicide one after another in recent years.

Firefighters in Trouble?

As the firefighters union NZPFU continue to fight for things like mental health resilience training, (the same which ambulance staff undergo) Fire and Emergency New Zealand continue to post end-of-year reports showing a 60 million dollars surplus. If there is a 60 million dollar surplus why aren't firefighters being supported to do their jobs as best they can? FENZ if they wanted to, could put every professional and volunteer firefighter in New Zealand through a mental health first aid course and still operate on a 55 million dollar surplus. It could even go further and spend another 20 million by putting every firefighter through 4 months of counselling with an organisation like Betterhelp and still leave a 30 million dollar surplus.

The problems aren't just specific to mental health however, some brigades are working with equipment which hasn't been renewed in over a decade leading to regular breakages of essential equipment.

Contrary to what one might think, Brendan's attitude to all of this is not one of despair and he's not one to let frustration get the better of him. Instead of being bitter at his truck not starting for example, he focuses on how he can better his interpersonal skills to let those at the call-out know why he's late. He carries out his duty without blame or resentment directed at anyone. His view is that his suffering has made him stronger. That's really the only constructive way to look at adversity. I take my hat off to him.

Firefighters surely have to be some of the best people our society has to offer. Men and women willing to risk their lives in an effort to help others. It's a job they have a great passion for, obviously. Brendan tells me, because of exposure to smoke a fireman is 5 times more likely to get prostate cancer and yet still gets up and puts his uniform on each day. People like this have incentive from the noblest places a human heart and mind can draw inspiration. A genuine passion for helping others no matter what the cost. What's not to admire about that?

It should be simple. These men and women need certain tools to do their job and they are going without. That's all it boils down to. We wouldn't expect a builder to work without tools. We wouldn't expect an accountant to work without having basic numerical skills.

Since 2013 the job for firefighters has changed and changed radically. It's only reasonable that their training and support change in fitting with their duties... isn't it?

To show our gratitude, Kiwis For Good welcomes all professional and volunteer Kiwi Firefighters to use our free counselling service until such time disputes between NZPFU and FENZ are resolved.

You can support our firefighters today by sharing this article with your friends and family and signing our petition below. 

Petition of Kiwis For Good: Help our firefighters resolve disputes - New Zealand Parliament (www.parliament.nz)

Sign the Petition

 

An Interview with Whitty Whitmore - WW2 & Hiroshima Social IssuesCulture An Interview with Whitty Whitmore - WW2 & Hiroshima Whitty Whitmore was born in Tauranga in 1924. He lost his father at 11 and at 15 signed up to fight in WW2, where he was sent to Italy where he fought in The Battle of Monte Cassino. He has battled and overcome mental health struggles. A true survivor, we are honoured to be able to share his story with you now. Read New Zealand Launches Suicide Prevention Action Plan 2025–2029 Social Issues New Zealand Launches Suicide Prevention Action Plan 2025–2029 The Suicide Prevention Action Plan 2025–2029 builds on the 2019 'Every Life Matters' strategy and sets out a focused, time-bound series of actions aimed at saving lives and improving outcomes for vulnerable communities. Read Welcoming Dr Robin Youngson: A Groundbreaking Trauma Specialist and Trustee of Kiwis For Good Social Issues Welcoming Dr Robin Youngson: A Groundbreaking Trauma Specialist and Trustee of Kiwis For Good Kiwis For Good is proud to announce the appointment of Dr Robin Youngson as a Trustee of our organisation. Dr Youngson is a leading trauma specialist and the founder of a pioneering therapeutic practice known as Somatic Compassion – a powerful integration of neuroscience, affective touch, and compassionate presence that has transformative effects on trauma healing. Read My long road to redemption. Social IssuesCulture My long road to redemption. There was once a time when my parents feared for my future. I was a wayward child, but all children are to varying degrees, so it didn’t arouse much concern. At first. Read An ex soldiers battle after leaving the army PoliticsBusinessSocial Issues An ex soldiers battle after leaving the army Karl had dreamed of joining the military since he was a little kid. He thrived on pressure and enjoyed pushing himself, so was thrilled when his dream came true. Unfortunately for Karl, the idea of being in the military was better than the reality of it. Read The Transformational Power of Human Connection: Why Our Mental Health System Needs More Than Pills and Protocols Social IssuesCulture The Transformational Power of Human Connection: Why Our Mental Health System Needs More Than Pills and Protocols In 2005, a young man stood on the edge of the Golden Gate Bridge, ready to end his life. Ninety minutes later, he stepped back from the ledge — alive. What changed? Read
Help Us Help Others!

Your donations are incredibly important for us, and enable us to use our initiatives to help our fellow Kiwis.

Donate today
Join Our Newsletter

For the latest news and projects, keep up-to-date with our newsletter. We promise not to spam you; we get enough of that ourselves!