Legalised Extortion: The Dark World of New Zealand’s Debt Buyers

Social IssuesCulture Dec 11, 2024 Mitch Dyer

I was halfway through my second cup of coffee in the dim corner of a back-alley cafe when I received a tip-off about the shadowy practice of junk debt buying. The email was cryptic, almost paranoid, and signed with the initials P.A.H. It read: "If you want to understand how modern financial predators operate, follow the junk debt trail. Start with Maryland, but the rot spreads everywhere."

I thought it was a hoax, some melodramatic finance geek trying to pull me into a rabbit hole. But the attachment caught my eye — a paper titled "Defending Junk-Debt-Buyer Lawsuits" by Peter A. Holland. And just like that, I was hooked.

The Grubby Details

Junk debt buying is the bastard offspring of capitalism's ugliest instincts. Picture this: a big-name bank or telecom company writes off unpaid debts as a loss. These debts are bundled together, stripped of context or proof, and sold off for pennies on the dollar to the vultures of the financial world — junk debt buyers.

These buyers then go to court, armed with almost no evidence, demanding full payment from unsuspecting consumers. It’s a simple business model: pay $100 for a $10,000 debt portfolio, bully a few poor souls into paying up, and rake in the profits. The data is incomplete, the claims are dubious, and the courts? Often complicit.

“It’s legalised extortion,” said one lawyer I spoke to, who has defended clients in these cases. “The junk debt buyers know the system favours them. Most people don’t have the means to fight back.”

The Courtroom Circus

Fast-forward to the Hastings District Court in New Zealand, where a company called Intercoll Ledger Limited recently tried to take Kiwis For Good to task for a debt it supposedly inherited. Their case was riddled with holes: no proof of a contract, no evidence of any actual debt transfer, just a pile of paper and the hope that the defendant would fold.

Judge Collins wasn’t having it. The case was dismissed. A rare win for the little guy, but the fact that it even reached court shows how far this racket has infiltrated the legal system.

Junk Debt’s Weapon: Fear

If you’ve ever received one of those menacing letters or calls about an unpaid bill you barely remember, you’ve already met the junk debt ecosystem. It thrives on confusion and fear. The letters are intentionally vague, the phone calls scripted to intimidate. “Most of the time, they can’t prove a thing,” said Tim Baker, CEO of Kiwis For Good. “But people panic and pay anyway. That’s what these companies count on.”

The Global Scam

This isn’t just a New Zealand problem. In the U.S., Visiting Assistant Professor Peter A. Holland has dedicated his career to exposing junk debt buyers. His research shows how these companies exploit the courts, relying on default judgments against consumers who don’t know how to defend themselves.

Holland’s work is a treasure map for anyone looking to understand the global nature of this scam. The same tricks, the same lack of evidence, the same reliance on overwhelmed court systems — it’s a cookie-cutter operation replicated worldwide.

Fighting Back

The good news? The tide is turning. Organisations like Kiwis For Good are arming consumers with knowledge. Their "Three-Letter Process" has become a blueprint for disputing unverified debt claims. Step one: demand proof. Step two: challenge their response. Step three: call their bluff. It’s simple, effective, and free.

“The more people fight back, the less profitable this becomes,” Baker said. “But we need more awareness. This is a war, and the battlefield is the courts.”

The Last Word

Junk debt buying is a parasitic practice that preys on the vulnerable. It’s the financial equivalent of a schoolyard bully, demanding your lunch money without a shred of justification. But the days of unchecked power might just be numbered. Thanks to the work of whistleblowers, lawyers, and grassroots organisations, the cracks in the system are beginning to show.

As I closed the Holland report and finished my coffee, one thought lingered: if these companies are betting on our ignorance, maybe it’s time we stop being such a safe bet.

The challenges of discontinuing antidepressants were never adequately conveyed to me. Social Issues The challenges of discontinuing antidepressants were never adequately conveyed to me. When I decided to stop taking antidepressants, the withdrawal symptoms hit me hard. I experienced daily panic attacks, vertigo, brain zaps, and intense anxiety for the initial three months. Tasks as simple as holding a cup of coffee became precarious, with tears a daily occurrence. The challenges of discontinuing antidepressants were never adequately conveyed to me. Read What are Depression & Anxiety? Social IssuesCulture What are Depression & Anxiety? There is a desperate and growing need in NZ for children and parents alike to understand what depression and anxiety actually are. This short animation was made with the oversight of a child psychiatrist and counsellors. It presents these emotions in a way that removes the stigma and brings about clarity for the child so that when he or she does inevitably feel these feelings, they can see it as a normal part of life. Read Surge in SSRI Prescriptions Raises Concerns for Youth Mental Health Social Issues Surge in SSRI Prescriptions Raises Concerns for Youth Mental Health Disturbing trends have emerged from recent data provided by the Ministry of Health in New Zealand revealing a fourfold increase in SSRI prescriptions for children aged 19 and under from 2010 to 2021. Read My Recovery from Abuse - Jessica Emily Social IssuesCulture My Recovery from Abuse - Jessica Emily Kiwis For Good are proud to introduce Jessica Emily. Jessica has been featured in Woman’s Day and various other publications sharing her journey. She is a leading Empowerment/Mental health Coach, public speaker and recovery enthusiast. Read Unpacking the Impact of Mental Health Awareness: Could It Be Making Things Worse? Social Issues Unpacking the Impact of Mental Health Awareness: Could It Be Making Things Worse? A new study called "A Closer Look at the Mental Health Awareness Effect" delves into the potential consequences of recent campaigns aiming to shed light on mental health issues. Researchers Lucy Foulkes and Jack L. Andrews suggest that these campaigns, while trying to help, might actually be part of the reason why more people are reporting mental health problems. Read What makes someone a narcissist? Social Issues What makes someone a narcissist? The best way I can sum up what over 20 years of knowing a narc is, is this way... Read
Help Us Help Others!

Your donations are incredibly important for us, and enable us to use our initiatives to help our fellow Kiwis.

Donate today
Join Our Newsletter

For the latest news and projects, keep up-to-date with our newsletter. We promise not to spam you; we get enough of that ourselves!