Surge in SSRI Prescriptions Raises Concerns for Youth Mental Health

Social Issues Sep 09, 2023 Tim Baker

Disturbing trends have emerged from recent data provided by the Ministry of Health in New Zealand revealing a fourfold increase in SSRI prescriptions for children aged 19 and under from 2010 to 2021.

The numbers reveal a dramatic increase in the prescription of Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitors (SSRIs) to children aged 19 and under, with prescription rates soaring from 40,146 in 2010 to a staggering 160,299 in 2021. These statistics raise pressing questions about the safety and necessity of these medications, particularly in light of controversial research surrounding Study 329.

SSRIs, a class of antidepressants including well-known drugs like Prozac and Paxil, have experienced a significant surge in prescriptions among New Zealand's youth. However, this increase has prompted critical scrutiny, given the complex scientific landscape surrounding depression and serotonin levels in the brain, as highlighted by Dr. Joanna Moncrieff's research.

Dr. Moncrieff's work, including her study available at Nature.com, challenges the conventional belief that low serotonin levels in the brain directly cause depression. Instead, her research suggests a more intricate mechanism of action for SSRIs, casting doubt on their role in treating depression.

The Ministry of Health data paints a striking picture. In 2010, approximately 40,146 SSRI prescriptions were issued to children aged 19 and under in New Zealand. Fast forward to 2021, and that number has surged to a staggering 160,299, representing a fourfold increase in just over a decade. This alarming escalation prompts a pivotal question: why are SSRIs being increasingly prescribed to young individuals when the scientific underpinnings are facing scrutiny?

The stark rise in SSRI prescriptions corresponds disturbingly with a 30% increase in youth suicide rates during the same period, pushing New Zealand to claim the highest youth suicide rate within the OECD.

Dr. Emma Lawson, a mental health specialist, comments, "The correlation between the mounting SSRI prescriptions and the surge in youth suicide rates necessitates an urgent examination of our approach to youth mental health care. We must explore alternative, evidence-based interventions that delve into the root causes of mental health challenges in young people."

The shadow of controversy looms large with the enigmatic Study 329. The study, published in the Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry (JAACAP) in 2001, concluded that Paxil (paroxetine) was a safe and effective treatment for children and adolescents with major depression. However, subsequent investigations have cast a long shadow of doubt over the study's methodology, credibility, and implications.

Study 329's impact was profound, with Paxil becoming GlaxoSmithKline's (GSK) bestselling drug, despite mounting evidence of its ineffectiveness and potential harm to young patients. Legal actions and settlements ensued, but the consequences had already been felt.

The Study 329 saga underscores broader issues within the pharmaceutical industry, including the imperative for transparency in clinical trials and the need for unrestricted access to comprehensive data. Restoring Study 329, a reanalysis and rebuttal of the original study, has challenged the earlier conclusions and raised questions about drug safety and the limitations of randomized controlled trials.

As New Zealand grapples with the concerning surge in SSRI prescriptions for children aged 19 and under, it is paramount for healthcare professionals, policymakers, and the public to engage in an earnest dialogue about the role of these medications in youth mental health care. The data and controversies underscore the urgency of pursuing evidence-based approaches that prioritize the safety and well-being of the nation's most vulnerable population: its youth.

The NZ wellbeing budget - An historic moment in our nations history. PoliticsBusinessSocial Issues The NZ wellbeing budget - An historic moment in our nations history. New Zealand's Labour coalition government has done something that could prove historic. Led by Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern, it has produced the world's first "wellbeing" Budget, focused explicitly on a single goal: using its limited funds to promote the wellbeing of its citizens. Read New Zealand’s Drinking Culture and the Shadow It Casts on Mental Health Social Issues New Zealand’s Drinking Culture and the Shadow It Casts on Mental Health Alcohol, long considered a social cornerstone in New Zealand, has once again come under scrutiny, this time sparked by comments from mental health advocate Mike King. King suggested that, in some cases, alcohol may have prevented individuals from taking their own lives by numbing overwhelming distress. Read Tim Baker - The Early Years. Social IssuesCulture Tim Baker - The Early Years. I was four years old. We were packing the car with stuff, more stuff than just the usual groceries or a trip to the dump. Mum was calm, dad seemed sombre... Read Bungee Jumping's Forgotten Pioneer BusinessSocial IssuesTechnologyCulture Bungee Jumping's Forgotten Pioneer The first time I met David Kirke, New Zealand's forgotten pioneer and the worlds first bungee jumper. Who you ask? Most people in New Zealand would never have heard the name David Kirke the man that created the now quintessentially Kiwi extreme sport with an illegal jump from the Clifton Suspension Bridge in 1979 at the city of Bristol, England. Read Is Toxoplasma Gondii the Hidden Culprit Behind Mental Health Crises? Why Parasite Treatment Should Be a Top Priority in Psychiatry Social Issues Is Toxoplasma Gondii the Hidden Culprit Behind Mental Health Crises? Why Parasite Treatment Should Be a Top Priority in Psychiatry For years, the mental health field has diligently sought answers to the root causes of depression, anxiety, schizophrenia, and—most tragically—suicidal behaviour. We often look for obvious culprits: trauma, substance abuse, environmental stress, or familial history of mental illness. But what if the real cause of these debilitating conditions is far more insidious, microscopic, and commonly overlooked? Read A Journey of Tribulation & Triumph Social IssuesCulture A Journey of Tribulation & Triumph So far my journey with anxiety and depression has gone on for forty years or close to it. They have been part of my life for as long as I can remember. In some ways I have been really lucky but as is the case with most people there have been ups and downs. Read
Help Us Help Others!

Your donations are incredibly important for us, and enable us to use our initiatives to help our fellow Kiwis.

Donate today
Join Our Newsletter

For the latest news and projects, keep up-to-date with our newsletter. We promise not to spam you; we get enough of that ourselves!